Town of Arlington
Home MenuThorndike Place Comprehensive Permit Application
Final Decision
On Monday, November 22, 2021 the Zoning Board of Appeals voted to grant the applicant a comprehensive permit with conditions for this project. View the final decision.
The signed decision on the application for a comprehensive permit was filed with the Town Clerk on December 1, 2021. View the signed decision.
General Information
Project Summary
Thorndike Place is a proposed rental and ownership residential community to be located on a 17.7-acre parcel of land, located between Route 2/Concord Turnpike to the south and residential neighborhoods to the north and east. As originally proposed, the development included 12 ownership units to be housed in six (6) two-family townhouses and 207 rental units set farther back in a four (4)-story building, consisting of 104 one-bedroom units, 92 two-bedroom units and 23 three-bedroom units. Twenty-five percent (25%) of the housing units would have been available to households earning no more than 80% of Area Median Income, adjusted for household size, for the Boston-Cambridge-Quincy HMFA area.
The proposal was revised in March 2020 with some updated information, but without major design changes. After a review of the environmental concerns raised by the Town, the Applicant proposed a major redesign in September 2020. This revision, proposed a decrease in the scale of the building and a consolidation of the construction area to reduce its impact on wetlands and flooding on the property. After a review by the Town, the Applicant prepared detailed designs for resubmission.
The revised proposal, submitted in November 2020, proposed to eliminate the two-family townhouses and locate a reduced size four (4) story building directly on Dorothy Road. The total number of rental units is reduced to 176 units, 25% (44 units) of which would be permanently affordable to low and moderate income families. The proposal includes 11 studio units, 87 one-bedroom units, 58 two-bedroom units, and 20 three-bedroom units.
The proposal was revised in May 2021 and updated in June to reintroduce six (6) two-family townhouses along the frontage of Dorothy Road, as was presented in the original Comprehensive Permit Application. A four-story senior independent living facility is proposed for the parcel to the rear of the townhomes. The total number of rental units is reduced to 124 units, 25% (31 units) of which would be permanently affordable to low and moderate income families. The proposal includes 43 studio units, 58 one-bedroom units, and 23 two-bedroom units.
Arlington Town Bylaws in Effect at the Time of the Original Application
The following editions of Town Bylaws were in effect at the time of the August 2016 application, and they continue to be the local bylaws with which the Project needs to comply or be granted a waiver from the Zoning Board of Appeals through the Comprehensive Permit process under Massachusetts General Law Chapter 40b.
Town of Arlington Zoning Bylaw with Amendments through April, 2016
Town of Arlington Regulations for Wetlands Protection dated June 4, 2015
November, 2021
- Draft Decisions
Thorndike Place Comprehensive Permit Draft Decision as of 11/18/2021
Thorndike Place Comprehensive Permit Draft Decision as of 11/11/2021
October 2021
- Draft Decision for October 21, 2021 Hearing
Thorndike Place Comprehensive Permit Draft Decision, provided October 13, 2021
- Draft Decision for October 5, 2021 Hearing
Thorndike Place Comprehensive Permit Draft Decision, provided September 30, 2021
Applicant Markup of Draft Decision, dated September 24, 2021
- Applicant Materials
VAI email to Stephanie Kiefer re: Thorndike Place TDM Clarification, dated October 1, 2021
Memorandum from John Hession, PE re: Thorndike Place - Flooding Mitigation Measures, dated October 4, 2021
- Peer Review Comments
BETA Review of Applicant Flood Mitigation Memo, dated October 8, 2021
Joint Comment Letter: ACC & BETA [Eight (8th) Set of Comments from ACC], dated October 14, 2021
- Supplementary Information
Trip Generation Basics, Chapter 2, Trip Generation Handbook, 3rd Edition
Description of the Database, Chapter 4, Trip Generation Handbook, 3rd Edition
Trip Generation, Land Use: 220 (Multifamily Housing, Low-Rise), Trip Generation Handbook, 3rd Edition
Trip Generation, Land Use: 221 (Multifamily Housing, Mid-Rise), Trip Generation Handbook, 3rd Edition
Trip Generation, Land Use: 251 (Senior Adult Housing--Detached), Trip Generation Handbook, 3rd Edition
Trip Generation, Land Use: 252 (Senior Adult Housing--Attached), Trip Generation Handbook, 3rd Edition
Trip Generation, Land Use: 255 (Continuing Care Retirement Community), Trip Generation Handbook, 3rd Edition
- Public Comment
Public Comment Received for October 5, 2021 Public Hearing
September 2021
- Applicant Materials
Smolak & Vaughan Cover Letter to Christian Klein, dated September 2, 2021
VAI Letter re: Responses to Peer Review Comments, dated September 2, 2021
Smolak & Vaughan Response to BETA Waiver List Review, dated September 2, 2021
Smolak & Vaughan Response to ACC's Seventh Comment Letter, dated September 2, 2021
Smolak & Vaughan Cover Letter to Christian Klein re: DPCD comment letter, dated September 2, 2021
GreenStaxx Architectural Package, dated September 2, 2021
Thorndike Place List of Requested Waivers, dated September 2, 2021
- Peer Review Comments on August 31, 2021 Submission
BETA Group, Inc. letter to Jennifer Raitt re: Comprehensive Permit Civil/Wetland Peer Review #5, dated September 8, 2021
BETA Group, Inc. memorandum to Jennifer Raitt re: Thorndike Place – 40B Peer Review Compensatory Storage and Restoration Cost Estimate, dated September 20, 2021
- Public Comment
Public Comment Received for September 9, 2021 Public Hearing
Arlington Land Trust / Brian Rehrig comments on Flooding/Stormwater and Open Space Need, dated September 28, 2021; documents referenced in this letter are provided below:- Arlington Redevelopment Board Minutes, dated March 30, 2015
- Conservation Commission letter to Kevin Greeley re: Site Approval Application for Thorndike Place, dated August 6, 2015
- Metropolitan District Commission letter to Secretary Durand, dated October 19, 2000
- Metropolitan District Commission Land Acquisition Program, no date
- Nover-Armstrong Associates letter to Town Counsel re: Notice of Eligibility for 40B Site Eligibility Letter, dated August 10, 2015
August 2021
- Submission 2: August 31, 2021
BSC Group Response to Town of Arlington Review, dated August 31, 2021
BSC Group Turning Movement Exhibits, updated August 27, 2021
BSC Group Response to BETA Civil/Wetland Peer Review, dated August 31, 2021
BSC Group Site/Civil Drawings, updated August 27, 2021
BSC Group Stormwater Report, revised August, 2021
BSC Group Potential Conservation Parcel, revised August 27, 2021
- Peer Review Comments on August 2, 2021 Submission
BETA Group, Inc. Letter to Jennifer Raitt re: Comprehensive Permit Civil/Wetland Peer Review #4, dated August 18, 2021
BETA Group, Inc. Letter to Christian Klein re: Thorndike Place Requested Waivers, dated August 17, 2021
BETA Group, Inc. Letter to Jennifer Raitt re: Development Changes - Traffic Considerations Review, dated August 10, 2021
- Department/Board Comments on August 2, 2021 Submission
Arlington Conservation Commission letter re: Seventh Set of Comments from Conservation Commission, dated August 23, 2021
Department of Planning and Community Development memorandum re: Thorndike Place Comments from Department of Planning and Community Development, dated August 23, 2021
- Submission 1: August 2, 2021
Smolak & Vaughan Cover Letter re: Supplemental Architectural Materials, dated August 2, 2021
GreenSTAXX Resubmission of Architectural Plan Set, dated July 26, 2021
BSC Group Cover Letter re: Response to BETA Civil/Wetland Peer Review, dated August 3, 2021
Smolak & Vaughan Project Overview, dated August 3, 2021
BSC Group Layout Plan, dated August 2, 2021
BSC Group Grading Plan, dated August 2, 2021
BSC Group Conservation Parcel, dated August 2, 2021
BSC Group Ambulance Turning Exhibit, dated August 2, 2021
Vanasse & Associates, Inc. Modular Truck Entering Site Diagram, no date
Vanasse & Associates, Inc. Modular Truck Exiting Site Diagram, no date
BSC Group Utility Plan, dated August 2, 2021
Vanasse & Associates, Inc. Cover Letter re: Response to Peer Review Comments, dated August 3, 2021
Vanasse & Associates, Inc. Revised Traffic Analysis and Response to ZBA Comments, dated August 3, 2021
Thorndike Place List of Requested Waivers, updated August 3, 2021
July 2021
- Public Comment
Public Comment Received for July 13, 2021 Public Hearing
June 2021
- Applicant Materials
Smolak & Vaughan Cover Letter re: Supplemental Materials for Revised Project Concept Plans, dated June 8, 2021
BSC Group Layout Plans and Materials dated June 3, 2021
BSC Group Stormwater Report, revised June 2021
GreenSTAXX Revised Architectural Plan Set, dated June 3, 2021
Vanasse & Associates Inc. Traffic Considerations Regarding Development Changes, dated June 8, 2021
- Public Comment
Public Comment Received for June 10, 2021 Public Hearing
May 2021
- Transmittal Letters and Memoranda
Smolak & Vaughan Cover Letter re: Revised Project Concept Plans, dated May 10, 2021
Submission Binder for Revised Concept, dated May 10, 2021
- Department Comments to May 2021 Submission
ACC Comments regarding revised site plan, dated May 28, 2021
- Public Comment
Public Comment Received for May 13, 2021 Public Hearing
April 2021
- Public Comment
Public Comment Received for April 8, 2021 Public Hearing
March 2021
- Applicant Materials
BSC Group Response to BETA Civil/Wetland Peer Review #3, dated March 11, 2021
BSC Group Response to BETA NOAA 14+ Stormwater Analysis, dated March 10, 2021
BSC Group Layout Plan and Materials, dated March 3, 2021
Vanasse & Associates Inc Response to Peer Review Comments, dated March 11, 2021
- Departmental/Committee Comments
Open Space Committee letter to ZBA dated March 29, 2021
ACC Recommended Revisions to Draft Decision, dated March 18, 2021
Select Board Letter to Mass Housing, dated March 15, 2021
Town Manager Letter to ZBA re: Thorndike Place Conditions for Transfer of Land, dated March 11, 2021
- Public Comment
Public Comment Received for March 11, 2021 Public Hearing
January 2021 Revision
- Transmittal Letters and Memoranda
BSC Group Stormwater Report dated January 18, 2021
BSC Group Stormwater Review Response Letter dated January 22, 2021
BSC Group Traffic Impact Review Response Letter dated January 25, 2021
BSC Group Response to Weston & Sampson Resiliency Review dated February 16, 2021
BSC Group Response 2 to Peer Review Comments dated February 16, 2021
Fougere Planning Fiscal Impact Analysis dated January 8, 2021
Smolak & Vaughan LLP Responses to DPCD Memorandum dated February 16, 2021
VAI Responses to TAC Comment Letter dated February 1, 2021
VAI Revised Traffic Volume Networks Capacity Analysis January 13, 2021
City of Cambridge VOX on 2 Transportation Impact Study dated December 11, 2019
- Drawings and Plans
BSC Group Revised Site Plans dated January 21, 2021
BSC Group 3D Visualizations and Illustrations dated February 16, 2021
- Wetlands Delineation Documentation
BSC Group Revised Wetlands Delineation Memorandum dated January 18, 2021
- Department Comments to January 2021 Submission
ACC Recommended Permit Conditions Letter dated February 1, 2021
ACC Recommended Permit Conditions Letter dated February 5, 2021
Sewer System Schematic - Dorothy Road
Water System Schematic - Dorothy Road
- Consultant Comments to January 2021 Submission
BETA Responses to Traffic Peer Review Comments dated February 1, 2021
BETA Wetland Peer Review dated February 12, 2021
BETA Mode Split and Transportation Demand Management Review dated February 16, 2021
- Public Comments to January 2021 Submission
Arlington Land Trust Letter dated February 15, 2021
Public Comment Received for January 26, 2021 Public Hearing
Public Comment Received for February 9, 2021 Public Hearing
Public Comment Received for February 16, 2021 Public Hearing
November 2020 Revision
- Transmittal Letters and Memoranda
BSC Group Transmittal Letter dated November 3, 2020
Smolak & Vaughan LLP Narrative Report dated November 3, 2020
Smolak & Vaughan LLP Statement of Master Plan Compliance dated November 3, 2020
Smolak & Vaughan LLP Revised List of Requested Waivers dated November 3, 2020
BSC Group Stormwater Report dated November 3, 2020
BSC Group Wildlife Habitat and Vegetation Evaluation dated November 3, 2020
Vanasse & Associates Transportation Impact Assessment dated November, 2020
Vanasse & Associates Letter to DPCD dated January 15, 2021
Vanasse & Associates Appendix to DPCD Letter dated January 15, 2021
- Drawings and Plans
Thorndike Place Architectural Drawing Set dated November 3, 2020
Thorndike Place Civil Drawing Set dated November 3, 2020
- Wetlands Delineation Documentation
BSC Group Wetlands Delineation Memorandum dated October 19, 2020
BSC Group Wetlands Delineation Plan dated October 22, 2020
BSC Group Wetlands Delineation Field Data Forms (undated)
BSC Group Transmittal Letter dated October 22, 2020
- Department Comments to November 2020 Submission
Engineering Division Memorandum dated December 3, 2020
Engineering Division Memorandum dated December 4, 2020
Arlington Conservation Commission Letter dated November 20, 2020
Arlington Conservation Commission Comments to December 8, 2020 Hearing
Arlington Transportation Advisory Committee Letter dated January 6, 2021
Planning & Community Development Comments dated January 8, 2021
Inspectional Services Comments dated December 7, 2020
Arlington Fire Department Comments dated December 7, 2020
- Consultant Comments to November 2020 Submission
BETA Group Review of Revised Site Plan dated November 20, 2020
BETA Group Review of Transportation Impact Assessment dated December 1, 2020
- Official Correspondence - Arlington Zoning Board of Appeals
Revised Hearing Schedule Memorandum dated September 15, 2020
Revised Hearing Schedule Memorandum dated November 22, 2020
Smolak & Vaughan LLP Schedule Extension Letter dated October 19, 2020
September 2020 Revision
- Transmittal Letters and Memoranda
BSC Group Transmittal Letter dated September 28, 2020
Smolak & Vaughan Response to Completeness Review dated September 25, 2020
- Drawings and Plans
Rendered Site Plan with Wetland Boundaries dated March 13, 2020
Revised Rendered Site Plan with Wetland Boundaries (undated)
- Department Comments to September 2020 Submission
Arlington Conservation Commission Letter dated October 9, 2020
Arlington Conservation Commission Comments to October 13, 2020 Hearing
- Consultant Comments to September 2020 Submission
BETA Group Review of Revised Site Plan dated October 8, 2020
- Public Comments to September 2020 Submission
Public Comment Received for October 13, 2020 Public Hearing
March 2020 Revision
- Transmittal Letters and Memoranda
Smolak & Vaughan LLP Transmittal Letter dated March 19, 2020
Smolak & Vaughan Response to Completeness Review dated March 18, 2020
BSC Group Transmittal Letter dated March 16, 2020
- Drawings and Plans
Revised Architectural Plan Set dated March 11, 2020
Revised Civil Engineering Plan Set Dated March 16, 2020
- Department Comments to March 2020 Submission
Arlington Redevelopment Board Letter dated July 7, 2020
Arlington Transportation Advisory Committee Email dated June 18, 2020
Arlington Select Board Letter dated July 7, 2020
Arlington Inspectional Services Department Letter dated July 3, 2020
Arlington Open Space Committee Letter dated July 6, 2020
Arlington Fire Department Email dated June 22, 2020
Arlington Conservation Commission Letter dated July 9, 2020
Rizzo ANRAD Report dated July 11, 2000
Rizzo ANRAD Plan dated October 18, 2000
- Consultant Comments to March 2020 Submission
KP Review of Response to Original Completeness Review Memorandum dated July 7, 2020
BETA Group Review of Environmental, Civil, and Stormwater Elements dated August 5, 2020
BETA Group Review of Traffic Study dated July 29, 2020
Original August 2016 Application
- Applicant Materials
Application for Comprehensive Permit dated August 31, 2016
Application Cover Letter dated August 31, 2016
Building Tabulation Data (undated)
Applicant Entity Information dated May 15, 2015
Evidence of Site Control dated October 27, 2015
Mass Housing Project Eligibility Letter dated December 4, 2015
List of Requested Wavers (undated)
Traffic Impact and Access Study (Draft) dated April, 2014
Mass Housing Sustainable Development Scorecard dated May 12, 2015
Preliminary Civil Engineering Plans dated February 24, 2015
Preliminary Landscape Plans dated February 24, 2015
Preliminary Architectural Plans and Elevations dated March 16, 2015
Certified List of Abutters dated August 16, 2016
Project Team & Contact Information (undated)
- Department Comments to August 2016 Application
Department Letters and Comments